 | Don Mattingly 1984 Topps Baseball #8 | Topps Baseball 1984 | PSA 8 $40.00 ▲21% | — | 61 |
 | Don Mattingly 1984 Donruss Baseball #248 | Donruss Baseball 1984 | PSA 8 $130 ▲4% | — | 51 |
 | Don Mattingly 1987 Topps Baseball #500 | Topps Baseball 1987 | PSA 10 $150 ▼2% | — | 14 |
 | Don Mattingly 1984 Fleer Baseball #131 | Fleer Baseball 1984 | PSA 9 $120 ▲6% | — | 10 |
 | Don Mattingly 1985 Donruss Baseball #295 | Donruss Baseball 1985 | PSA 9 $75.00 ▲25% | — | 9 |
 | Don Mattingly 1984 O-Pee-Chee Baseball #8 | O-Pee-Chee Baseball 1984 | PSA 9 $255 ▲6% | — | 8 |
 | Don Mattingly 1986 Topps Baseball #180 | Topps Baseball 1986 | PSA 9 $60.00 ▲13% | — | 7 |
 | Don Mattingly 1987 Topps Baseball No Trademark #606 | Topps Baseball 1987 | PSA 10 $49.99 ▼19% | — | 6 |
 | Don Mattingly 1985 Topps Baseball #665 | Topps Baseball 1985 | PSA 8 $14.99 ▲0% | — | 5 |
 | Don Mattingly 1990 Topps Baseball #200 | Topps Baseball 1990 | PSA 10 $69.99 ▼1% | — | 5 |
 | Don Mattingly 1995 Topps Baseball #399 | Topps Baseball 1995 | PSA 10 $99.95 ▼17% | — | 5 |
 | Don Mattingly 1986 Donruss Baseball #173 | Donruss Baseball 1986 | PSA 10 $74.40 ▼2% | — | 4 |
 | Don Mattingly 1987 Donruss Baseball #52 | Donruss Baseball 1987 | PSA 10 $72.00 ▼4% | — | 4 |
 | Don Mattingly 1989 Topps Baseball #700 | Topps Baseball 1989 | PSA 9 $25.00 ▲25% | — | 3 |
 | Don Mattingly 1993 Topps Baseball #32 | Topps Baseball 1993 | PSA 10 $38.99 ▼2% | — | 3 |
 | Don Mattingly 1988 Topps Baseball #300 | Topps Baseball 1988 | PSA 10 $61.50 ▲1% | — | 2 |
 | Don Mattingly 1984 Topps Baseball Tiffany #8 | Topps Baseball 1984 | PSA 8 $695 ▲9% | — | 2 |
 | Don Mattingly 1989 Donruss Baseball #74 | Donruss Baseball 1989 | PSA 10 $73.00 ▲38% | — | 2 |
 | Don Mattingly 1996 Topps Baseball #185 | Topps Baseball 1996 | PSA 10 $44.99 ▼6% | — | 2 |
 | Don Mattingly 1988 Topps Baseball All-Star #386 | Topps Baseball 1988 | PSA 9 $32.50 — | — | 2 |
 | Don Mattingly 1985 Fleer Baseball #133 | Fleer Baseball 1985 | PSA 10 $233 ▼24% | — | 1 |
 | Don Mattingly 1991 Topps Baseball #100 | Topps Baseball 1991 | PSA 10 $56.00 ▼31% | — | 1 |
 | Don Mattingly 1989 Upper Deck Baseball #200 | Upper Deck Baseball 1989 | PSA 9 $16.99 — | — | 1 |
 | Don Mattingly 1986 Topps Baseball All-Star #712 | Topps Baseball 1986 | PSA 9 $30.23 — | — | 1 |
 | Don Mattingly 1994 Topps Baseball #600 | Topps Baseball 1994 | PSA 10 $92.00 ▲37% | — | 1 |
 | Don Mattingly 1994 Flair Baseball Hot Gloves #6 | Flair Baseball 1994 | PSA 10 $215 ▼14% | — | 1 |
 | Don Mattingly 1984 Topps Nestle Baseball #8 | Topps Nestle Baseball 1984 | PSA 10 $2,050 — | — | 1 |
 | Don Mattingly 1992 Topps Stadium Club Baseball #420 | Topps Stadium Club Baseball 1992 | PSA 10 $96.00 — | — | 1 |
 | Don Mattingly 1988 Topps Baseball Record Breaker #2 | Topps Baseball 1988 | PSA 10 $74.40 — | — | 1 |
 | Don Mattingly 1994 Upper Deck Baseball #90 | Upper Deck Baseball 1994 | PSA 10 $99.99 — | — | 1 |
 | Don Mattingly 1985 Topps Tiffany Baseball #665 | Topps Tiffany Baseball 1985 | PSA 9 $116 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1991 Fleer Baseball Pro-Visions #11 | Fleer Baseball 1991 | PSA 8 $20.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1985 Donruss Baseball Diamond King #7 | Donruss Baseball 1985 | PSA 8 $18.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1987 Fleer Baseball #104 | Fleer Baseball 1987 | PSA 10 $199 ▼26% | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1989 Donruss Baseball Diamond Kings #26 | Donruss Baseball 1989 | PSA 8 $13.20 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1991 Topps Baseball Desert Shield #100 | Topps Baseball 1991 | PSA 9 $450 ▲11% | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1990 Donruss Baseball #190 | Donruss Baseball 1990 | PSA 10 $49.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1989 Upper Deck Baseball The Collector's Choice #693 | Upper Deck Baseball 1989 | PSA 9 $14.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1986 Topps Tiffany Baseball #180 | Topps Tiffany Baseball 1986 | PSA 8 $89.88 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1992 Fleer Baseball #237 | Fleer Baseball 1992 | PSA 10 $49.99 ▼31% | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1986 Topps Tiffany Baseball All-Star #712 | Topps Tiffany Baseball 1986 | PSA 9 $47.71 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1996 Fleer Baseball #189 | Fleer Baseball 1996 | PSA 10 $79.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1993 Donruss Baseball Elite #24 | Donruss Baseball 1993 | PSA 9 $185 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1992 Studio Baseball Heritage #BC-5 | Studio Baseball 1992 | PSA 10 $74.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1995 Donruss Baseball #55 | Donruss Baseball 1995 | PSA 10 $290 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1991 Leaf Studio Baseball #97 | Leaf Studio Baseball 1991 | PSA 10 $165 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1994 Fleer Baseball #239 | Fleer Baseball 1994 | PSA 9 $22.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1993 Fleer Ultra Baseball #244 | Fleer Ultra Baseball 1993 | PSA 10 $165 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1996 Upper Deck Baseball #154 | Upper Deck Baseball 1996 | PSA 10 $305 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1996 Metal Universe Baseball #90 | Metal Universe Baseball 1996 | PSA 9 $39.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1993 Topps Finest Baseball All-Star #98 | Topps Finest Baseball 1993 | PSA 9 $34.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1995 Studio Baseball #3 | Studio Baseball 1995 | PSA 9 $25.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1988 Topps Baseball Record Breaker #2 | Topps Baseball 1988 | PSA 10 $64.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 2024 Topps Update Baseball Legendary Home Field Advantage #LHA-13 | Topps Update Baseball 2024 | PSA 10 $300 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1986 Fleer Baseball #109 | Fleer Baseball 1986 | PSA 10 $675 ▲3% | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1994 Upper Deck Collector's Choice Baseball Gold Signature #355 | Upper Deck Collector's Choice Baseball 1994 | PSA 9 $30.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 2002 Topps Finest Baseball Finest Moments Autograph #FMA-DM | Topps Finest Baseball 2002 | PSA 8 $101 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1994 Donruss Baseball Diamond Kings #DK16 | Donruss Baseball 1994 | PSA 10 $608 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1994 SP Baseball Holoview F/X #25 | SP Baseball 1994 | PSA 10 $54.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1996 Pinnacle Baseball #307 | Pinnacle Baseball 1996 | PSA 8 $5.50 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1994 Fleer Sunoco Baseball #17 | Fleer Sunoco Baseball 1994 | PSA 9 $39.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 1994 Pinnacle Baseball Artist's Proof #23 | Pinnacle Baseball 1994 | PSA 10 $579 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 2024 Topps Pristine Baseball Gold Pristine #PA-DMA | Topps Pristine Baseball 2024 | PSA 10 $220 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 2026 Topps Baseball 1991 Topps Baseball Chrome Autographs #91C-29 | Topps Baseball 2026 | PSA 9 $200 — | — | 0 |
 | Don Mattingly 2003 Topps Baseball Record Breakers Autographs #RBA-DM | Topps Baseball 2003 | PSA 9 $154 — | — | 0 |
