 | Gary Carter 1975 Topps Baseball #620 | Topps Baseball 1975 | PSA 8 $197 ▼2% | — | 14 |
 | Gary Carter 1976 Topps Baseball #441 | Topps Baseball 1976 | PSA 8 $85.00 ▲21% | — | 5 |
 | Gary Carter 1984 Topps Baseball #450 | Topps Baseball 1984 | PSA 10 $79.95 — | — | 5 |
 | Gary Carter 1981 Topps Baseball #660 | Topps Baseball 1981 | PSA 9 $35.00 — | — | 2 |
 | Gary Carter 1980 Topps Baseball #70 | Topps Baseball 1980 | PSA 9 $57.12 ▼2% | — | 2 |
 | Gary Carter 1986 Donruss Baseball #68 | Donruss Baseball 1986 | PSA 10 $35.49 — | — | 2 |
 | Gary Carter 1989 Topps Baseball #680 | Topps Baseball 1989 | PSA 10 $34.00 — | — | 2 |
 | Gary Carter 1978 Topps Baseball #120 | Topps Baseball 1978 | PSA 8 $35.00 ▲46% | — | 1 |
 | Gary Carter 1977 Topps Baseball #295 | Topps Baseball 1977 | PSA 9 $162 — | — | 1 |
 | Gary Carter 1986 Topps Baseball #170 | Topps Baseball 1986 | PSA 8 $15.00 — | — | 1 |
 | Gary Carter 1983 Topps Baseball All-Star #404 | Topps Baseball 1983 | PSA 10 $49.00 ▲36% | — | 1 |
 | Gary Carter 1990 Topps Baseball #790 | Topps Baseball 1990 | PSA 10 $34.99 ▲46% | — | 1 |
 | Gary Carter / Dave Parker 1982 Fleer Baseball N.L. All-Stars #638 | Fleer Baseball 1982 | PSA 10 $59.99 — | — | 1 |
 | Gary Carter 1975 Topps Mini Baseball #620 | Topps Mini Baseball 1975 | PSA 7 $61.20 ▼10% | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1979 Topps Baseball #520 | Topps Baseball 1979 | PSA 8 $30.69 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1983 Topps Baseball #370 | Topps Baseball 1983 | PSA 8 $10.61 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1975 SSPC Baseball #334 | SSPC Baseball 1975 | PSA 9 $37.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1982 Topps Baseball #730 | Topps Baseball 1982 | PSA 9 $34.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1983 Fleer Baseball #278 | Fleer Baseball 1983 | PSA 10 $20.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1984 Donruss Baseball #55 | Donruss Baseball 1984 | PSA 10 $82.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1985 Topps Baseball #230 | Topps Baseball 1985 | PSA 10 $76.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1982 Donruss Baseball Diamond Kings #2 | Donruss Baseball 1982 | PSA 9 $19.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1984 Topps Baseball All-Star #393 | Topps Baseball 1984 | PSA 9 $17.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1982 Topps Baseball All-Star #344 | Topps Baseball 1982 | PSA 9 $15.53 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1989 Topps Baseball All-Star #393 | Topps Baseball 1989 | PSA 10 $24.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1981 Donruss Baseball #90 | Donruss Baseball 1981 | PSA 9 $20.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1991 Topps Baseball #310 | Topps Baseball 1991 | PSA 10 $32.08 ▼11% | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1987 Topps Baseball All-Star #602 | Topps Baseball 1987 | PSA 10 $36.09 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1982 Donruss Baseball #114 | Donruss Baseball 1982 | PSA 9 $14.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1986 Topps Baseball All-Star #708 | Topps Baseball 1986 | PSA 7 $10.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1988 Donruss Baseball #199 | Donruss Baseball 1988 | PSA 10 $62.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1989 Donruss Baseball #53 | Donruss Baseball 1989 | PSA 10 $64.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1991 Leaf Studio Baseball #182 | Leaf Studio Baseball 1991 | PSA 10 $89.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1992 Topps Stadium Club Baseball #845 | Topps Stadium Club Baseball 1992 | PSA 10 $64.65 — | — | 0 |
| Gary Carter 2003 Donruss Baseball 1992 Donruss #36 | Donruss Baseball 2003 | PSA 10 $16.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1976 O-Pee-Chee Baseball #441 | O-Pee-Chee Baseball 1976 | PSA 8 $172 — | — | 0 |
 | Gary Carter 1992 Topps Baseball #45 | Topps Baseball 1992 | PSA 8 $6.00 — | — | 0 |
