Gary Sheffield Card Prices

16 Gary Sheffield cards priced from recorded sales · 10 sales in the last 30 days

Every Gary Sheffield card we hold sales for, priced by grade from recorded sales. The most traded Gary Sheffield card this month is Gary Sheffield 1989 Topps Baseball Future Star #343 with 3 sales. The most valuable is Gary Sheffield 1997 Pinnacle Certified Baseball Mirror Gold Team #16 at $734 in PSA 6. Open any card for its chart, PSA population and every copy for sale right now.

Most traded Gary Sheffield cards

Card	Set	Most traded	Raw	30d
Gary Sheffield 1989 Topps Baseball Future Star #343	Topps Baseball 1989	PSA 10 $80.00 ▲60%	—	3
Gary Sheffield 1989 Fleer Baseball Autograph #196	Fleer Baseball 1989	PSA 10 $30.00 ▼20%	—	3
Gary Sheffield 1989 Upper Deck Baseball #13	Upper Deck Baseball 1989	PSA 10 $48.00 ▼13%	—	2
Gary Sheffield 1989 Donruss Baseball Autograph #31	Donruss Baseball 1989	PSA 10 $39.50 ▼18%	—	2
Gary Sheffield 1989 Bowman Baseball #142	Bowman Baseball 1989	PSA 10 $85.00 —	—	0
Gary Sheffield 1989 Bowman Tiffany Baseball #142	Bowman Tiffany Baseball 1989	PSA 9 $37.95 ▲1%	—	0
Gary Sheffield 1990 Topps Baseball #718	Topps Baseball 1990	PSA 9 $9.00 —	—	0
Gary Sheffield 1989 Fleer Baseball Glossy #196	Fleer Baseball 1989	PSA 9 $30.00 —	—	0
Gary Sheffield 1994 Topps Baseball #560	Topps Baseball 1994	PSA 10 $29.99 —	—	0
Gary Sheffield 1991 Topps Baseball #68	Topps Baseball 1991	PSA 10 $21.60 ▼11%	—	0
Gary Sheffield 1996 Topps Baseball #80	Topps Baseball 1996	PSA 10 $17.27 —	—	0
Gary Sheffield 1995 Topps Baseball #440	Topps Baseball 1995	PSA 9 $55.00 —	—	0
Gary Sheffield 2025 Topps Chrome Baseball Legend Autographs Red Refractor #CLA-GS	Topps Chrome Baseball 2025	PSA 9 $256 —	—	0
Gary Sheffield 1997 Pinnacle Certified Baseball Mirror Gold Team #16	Pinnacle Certified Baseball 1997	PSA 6 $734 —	—	0
Gary Sheffield 1997 Topps Baseball #264	Topps Baseball 1997	PSA 10 $11.99 —	—	0
Gary Sheffield 2003 Topps Baseball #130	Topps Baseball 2003	PSA 10 $150 —	—	0