John Elway Card Prices

Every John Elway card we hold sales for, priced by grade from recorded sales. The most traded John Elway card this month is John Elway 1984 Topps Football #63 with 134 sales. The most valuable is John Elway 1999 Skybox Metal Universe Football Precious Metal Gems #92 at $2,950 in PSA 6. Open any card for its chart, PSA population and every copy for sale right now.

Most traded John Elway cards

John Elway 1984 Topps Football #63

PSA 8 $170 ▲5% · 134/30d

John Elway 2024 Donruss Optic Football Uptowns #23

PSA 10 $284 ▼14% · 10/30d

John Elway 2025 Panini Phoenix Football Color Blast #25

PSA 10 $420 ▲0% · 8/30d

John Elway 1986 Topps Football #112

PSA 8 $6.50 ▼59% · 6/30d

John Elway 2024 Panini Prizm Draft Picks Football Color Blast #CB-28

PSA 10 $275 — · 2/30d

John Elway 1987 Topps Football #31

PSA 9 $37.50 ▼6% · 2/30d

John Elway 2021 Donruss Optic Football Downtown #DT-24

PSA 10 $821 ▼1% · 1/30d

John Elway 1989 Topps Football #241

PSA 10 $75.00 ▼25% · 1/30d

John Elway 1989 Pro Set Football #100

PSA 10 $91.00 — · 1/30d

John Elway 1998 Topps Chrome Football Season's Best Refractor #10

PSA 10 $492 — · 1/30d

John Elway 2025 Topps Chrome Football Tecmo #TECMO-11

PSA 9 $980 — · 1/30d

John Elway 1988 Topps Football All-Pro #23

PSA 8 $27.00 ▲23%

Every John Elway card we price

	Card	Set	Most traded	Raw	30d
	John Elway 1984 Topps Football #63	Topps Football 1984	PSA 8 $170 ▲5%	—	134
	John Elway 2024 Donruss Optic Football Uptowns #23	Donruss Optic Football 2024	PSA 10 $284 ▼14%	—	10
	John Elway 2025 Panini Phoenix Football Color Blast #25	Panini Phoenix Football 2025	PSA 10 $420 ▲0%	—	8
	John Elway 1986 Topps Football #112	Topps Football 1986	PSA 8 $6.50 ▼59%	—	6
	John Elway 2024 Panini Prizm Draft Picks Football Color Blast #CB-28	Panini Prizm Draft Picks Football 2024	PSA 10 $275 —	—	2
	John Elway 1987 Topps Football #31	Topps Football 1987	PSA 9 $37.50 ▼6%	—	2
	John Elway 2021 Donruss Optic Football Downtown #DT-24	Donruss Optic Football 2021	PSA 10 $821 ▼1%	—	1
	John Elway 1989 Topps Football #241	Topps Football 1989	PSA 10 $75.00 ▼25%	—	1
	John Elway 1989 Pro Set Football #100	Pro Set Football 1989	PSA 10 $91.00 —	—	1
	John Elway 1998 Topps Chrome Football Season's Best Refractor #10	Topps Chrome Football 1998	PSA 10 $492 —	—	1
	John Elway 2025 Topps Chrome Football Tecmo #TECMO-11	Topps Chrome Football 2025	PSA 9 $980 —	—	1
	John Elway 1988 Topps Football All-Pro #23	Topps Football 1988	PSA 8 $27.00 ▲23%	—	0
	John Elway 1990 Topps Football #37	Topps Football 1990	PSA 10 $415 —	—	0
	John Elway 2020 Donruss Optic Football Downtown #DT-24	Donruss Optic Football 2020	PSA 10 $2,000 —	—	0
	John Elway 1994 Topps Finest Football #119	Topps Finest Football 1994	PSA 8 $14.00 —	—	0
	John Elway 1991 Topps Football #554	Topps Football 1991	PSA 9 $25.00 —	—	0
	John Elway 1994 Topps Finest Football Refractor #119	Topps Finest Football 1994	PSA 9 $593 ▲20%	—	0
	John Elway 2023 Panini Prizm Football Blue Sparkle #89	Panini Prizm Football 2023	PSA 10 $70.00 —	—	0
	John Elway 2025 Panini Absolute Football KABOOM! Super Bowl Vertical #3	Panini Absolute Football 2025	PSA 10 $2,650 —	—	0
	John Elway 2024 Topps Chrome Football Urban Legends #UL-5	Topps Chrome Football 2024	PSA 10 $79.00 —	—	0
	John Elway 2024 Panini Prizm Football Choice Gold #89	Panini Prizm Football 2024	PSA 10 $261 —	—	0
	John Elway 1995 Fleer Ultra Football Gold Medallion #91	Fleer Ultra Football 1995	PSA 8 $25.00 —	—	0
	John Elway 1999 Topps Chrome Football Hall of Fame Refractor #H25	Topps Chrome Football 1999	PSA 9 $202 —	—	0
	John Elway 2024 Donruss Optic Football Uptowns Gold #23	Donruss Optic Football 2024	PSA 10 $2,150 —	—	0
	John Elway 1999 Skybox Metal Universe Football Precious Metal Gems #92	Skybox Metal Universe Football 1999	PSA 6 $2,950 —	—	0
	John Elway 2023 Panini Spectra Football Gold #103	Panini Spectra Football 2023	PSA 9 $550 —	—	0
	John Elway 2024 Panini Clearly Donruss Football Retro 1994 Autographs #9	Panini Clearly Donruss Football 2024	PSA 10 $325 —	—	0
	John Elway 2023 Panini Prizm Football Flashback Autographs Navy Camo #FA-JE	Panini Prizm Football 2023	PSA 10 $315 —	—	0