 | Walter Payton 1976 Topps Football #148 | Topps Football 1976 | PSA 4 $385 ▼4% | — | 106 |
 | Walter Payton 1987 Topps Football #46 | Topps Football 1987 | PSA 9 $67.85 ▼3% | — | 12 |
 | Walter Payton 1981 Topps Football All Pro #400 | Topps Football 1981 | PSA 8 $74.99 ▲36% | — | 11 |
 | Walter Payton 1977 Topps Football All-Pro #360 | Topps Football 1977 | PSA 6 $104 ▲0% | — | 10 |
 | Walter Payton 1984 Topps Football Instant Replay #229 | Topps Football 1984 | PSA 8 $26.00 ▲4% | — | 9 |
 | Walter Payton 1982 Topps Football In Action #303 | Topps Football 1982 | PSA 8 $48.00 ▼4% | — | 8 |
 | Walter Payton 1986 Topps Football #11 | Topps Football 1986 | PSA 8 $40.00 ▲14% | — | 6 |
 | Walter Payton 1979 Topps Football All-Pro #480 | Topps Football 1979 | PSA 8 $136 ▼9% | — | 6 |
 | Walter Payton 1988 Topps Football Record Breaker #5 | Topps Football 1988 | PSA 10 $115 ▼5% | — | 6 |
 | Walter Payton 1983 Topps Football #36 | Topps Football 1983 | PSA 9 $160 ▲37% | — | 6 |
 | Walter Payton 1982 Topps Football #302 | Topps Football 1982 | PSA 8 $43.29 ▼8% | — | 5 |
 | Walter Payton 1978 Topps Football All Pro #200 | Topps Football 1978 | PSA 8 $189 ▼12% | — | 3 |
 | Walter Payton 1980 Topps Football All Pro #160 | Topps Football 1980 | PSA 8 $85.00 ▼1% | — | 3 |
 | Walter Payton 1986 Topps Football Record Breaker #7 | Topps Football 1986 | PSA 8 $40.00 ▲19% | — | 3 |
 | Walter Payton 1985 Topps Football All-Pro #33 | Topps Football 1985 | PSA 8 $97.72 ▼19% | — | 2 |
 | Walter Payton 1978 Topps Football #3 | Topps Football 1979 | PSA 8 $52.00 — | — | 2 |
 | Walter Payton 2025 Topps Chrome Football Tecmo #TECMO-4 | Topps Chrome Football 2025 | PSA 9 $2,900 ▲4% | — | 2 |
 | Walter Payton 1978 Topps Football Highlights #3 | Topps Football 1978 | PSA 8 $56.01 ▼14% | — | 1 |
 | Walter Payton 1983 Topps Football Team Leaders #28 | Topps Football 1983 | PSA 8 $18.00 — | — | 1 |
 | Walter Payton 1977 Topps Football #333 | Topps Football 1978 | PSA 8 $48.00 — | — | 1 |
 | Walter Payton 1984 Topps Football Team Leader #221 | Topps Football 1984 | PSA 9 $64.99 — | — | 1 |
 | Walter Payton 2020 Donruss Optic Football Downtown #DT-28 | Donruss Optic Football 2020 | PSA 10 $4,300 — | — | 1 |
 | Walter Payton 2025 Topps Chrome Football Urban Legends #UL-30 | Topps Chrome Football 2025 | PSA 10 $436 ▲4% | — | 1 |
 | Walter Payton 1984 Topps Football #228 | Topps Football 1984 | PSA 8 $95.00 ▲32% | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton 1983 Topps Football Stickers #24 | Topps Football 1983 | PSA 8 $27.00 ▼5% | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton 1981 Topps Football Super Action #202 | Topps Football 1981 | PSA 8 $30.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton 1985 Topps Football Record Breaker #6 | Topps Football 1985 | PSA 6 $7.25 — | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton 1979 Topps Football Record Breaker #335 | Topps Football 1979 | PSA 8 $75.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton 1986 Topps Football 1000 Yard Club #3 | Topps Football 1986 | PSA 8 $60.00 — | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton / Eddie Payton 1982 Topps Football #269 | Topps Football 1982 | PSA 8 $24.99 — | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton 1985 Topps Baseball Yearbooks Coming Soon Stickers #156 | Topps Baseball 1985 | PSA 9 $66.80 — | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton 2021 Panini Prizm Football Red Ice #165 | Panini Prizm Football 2021 | PSA 10 $182 — | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton 2024 Topps Chrome Sapphire Football Gold #23 | Topps Chrome Sapphire Football 2024 | PSA 10 $304 — | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton 2025 Topps Chrome Football Image Variation #402 | Topps Chrome Football 2025 | PSA 10 $192 ▼3% | — | 0 |
 | Walter Payton 2025 Panini Prizm Black Football Prizmania #11 | Panini Prizm Black Football 2025 | PSA 10 $4,250 — | — | 0 |
| Walter Payton 2025 Topps Chrome Football Image Variation Black Geometric Refractor #402 | Topps Chrome Football 2025 | PSA 9 $800 — | — | 0 |
| Walter Payton 2024 Topps Chrome Sapphire Football Purple #23 | Topps Chrome Sapphire Football 2024 | PSA 10 $445 — | — | 0 |
